“I thought you would have handled this better.”
Just one sentence.
Five seconds, perhaps.
But those five seconds can set off quite a bit of activity inside!
There may be a little tightening somewhere. The breathing changes. Something shifts around the chest or stomach. An emotion appears. And before long, the mind has joined the conversation.
What does he mean by that?
I did the best I could.
Doesn't he know what I had to deal with?
And if the mind is in particularly good form that day, it may even retrieve something the same person said three years ago, with surprising speed and accuracy!
The sentence lasted five seconds.
The inner conversation can happily continue for the next five hours.
I find this fascinating.
What exactly happened between those few words reaching my ears and this whole experience unfolding inside me?
We might simply say:
“His comment upset me.”
Fair enough.
But did the comment really travel through the air carrying a small packet of hurt and deposit it somewhere inside me?
Obviously not.
Another person hearing exactly the same words might shrug, laugh, become angry, feel embarrassed or simply say, “You may be right.”
The words were the same.
The experience wasn't.
So something rather interesting must be happening between the situation outside and the experience inside.
That gap is the territory we are exploring in Figure 1.
Figure 1: What happens between event and experience?
That “something in between” is what I have been trying to understand.
I have started thinking of it as the Invisible Architecture of Human Experience.
Not as a grand new theory, I am certainly not proposing another branch of human anatomy!
It is simply an attempt to bring together some ideas I have been exploring about the body, energy, mind, emotions and the ancient understanding of our inner architecture.
Before the Mind Has Finished Thinking…
Let us hear that sentence again:
“I thought you would have handled this better.”
Before I have prepared my defence or counterattack, the body may already have responded.
The jaw tightens. The stomach contracts. The heartbeat changes. The breath becomes shallower.
Sometimes the body seems to have received the message before the mind has finished reading it!
We may also notice something harder to describe:
“I suddenly felt drained.”
“Something sank inside me.”
“My energy changed.”
Then the mind gets busy.
That was unfair.
He doesn't appreciate me.
Maybe he thinks I am incompetent.
The mind doesn't simply register what happened. It interprets it.
The same comment could become: “He thinks I am incompetent.” or “Maybe I could have handled that differently.”
Same words.
Very different inner experiences.
So perhaps we do not experience events quite as directly as we imagine. Something within us receives, reacts, interprets, remembers and gives meaning.
Our Sages Had Another Way of Looking at This
Long before brain scans, ECGs or EEGs, our sages were exploring human experience through observation, introspection, contemplation and meditation.
But how do we make sense of something as complex as ourselves?
One useful way is to create abstractions, simple conceptual maps that help us separate, observe and understand different aspects of something that, in actual experience, functions as an interconnected whole.
This is how I find it useful to look at the traditional ideas of the shariras and koshas.
They need not be imagined as separate physical structures hidden somewhere inside us. Rather, they offer different ways of organising our understanding of the human experience.
The three shariras give us one broad view:
Sthula Sharira - the gross or physical body
Sukshma Sharira - the subtle body
Karana Sharira - the causal body
The five koshas offer another, more differentiated view:
Annamaya Kosha - the physical sheath
Pranamaya Kosha - the vital-energy sheath
Manomaya Kosha - the mental-emotional sheath
Vijnanamaya Kosha - the sheath of discernment and understanding
Anandamaya Kosha - the innermost sheath, traditionally associated with bliss
Figure 2 brings these two ways of looking at our inner architecture together.
I don't find it particularly useful to imagine the koshas as five physical layers stacked neatly one inside another.
They become much more interesting if we ask:
Could they represent different dimensions through which our experience unfolds?
Our five-second criticism now becomes a useful little laboratory.
From Situation to Response: The Koshas at Work
The words are heard.
The body responds - the domain of Annamaya Kosha.
There is a shift in vitality or activation - Pranamaya Kosha.
Thoughts and emotions arise - Manomaya Kosha.
And perhaps, after a while, another faculty enters:
Wait. Why is this affecting me so strongly?
Is there some truth in what was said?
Do I really need to react immediately?
That brings in Vijnanamaya Kosha - perspective, discernment and the possibility of conscious choice.
Finally, something comes out into life.
I may argue, withdraw, explain myself, ask a question - or respond quite differently after reflecting.
Figure 3 shows how I find this model most useful: not as a conveyor belt through which experience travels in a fixed sequence, but as interacting dimensions continuously influencing one another.
From situation to response through the koshas
A thought can change the breath.
An emotion can alter our sense of energy.
Physical exhaustion can influence the mind.
Changing the breath can soften an emotional reaction.
A new understanding can change the whole experience.
The koshas are less like separate floors in a building and more like rooms in which everyone seems to be talking to everyone else!
That, for me, makes this ancient model much more alive.
Where Does the Subtle-Energy Architecture Fit?
Within this picture, Pranamaya Kosha deserves a closer look.
The nadis are traditionally described as pathways through which prana moves.
The chakras are described as important centres within this subtle-energy system.
And the granthis, literally “knots” point towards binding or attachment.
I would be cautious about treating these as physical anatomical structures waiting to be found by a medical scanner.
For me, their value lies in the questions they help us ask about our own experience.
Seven Chakras or Seven Recurring Human Concerns?
Consider how much of human life revolves around a surprisingly small number of concerns:
Security and stability.
Pleasure and relationship.
Confidence and personal power.
Love and connection.
Expression and communication.
Understanding and insight.
Meaning and transcendence.
These correspond closely with experiential themes traditionally associated with the seven chakras.
Figure 4 brings these themes together as a simple map of human experience.. from security and stabiility at Muladhara, through relationships, confidence, love and expression, to understanding and the search for meaning.
Now let us return to our critical comment.
Why did those few words affect me?
Did they disturb my sense of security?
Did I feel rejected?
Was my confidence or sense of competence challenged?
Did I feel unappreciated?
Was there something I wanted to express but couldn't?
The same comment can therefore touch different dimensions of our inner world and sometimes more than one at the same time.
This is one reason I find the chakra framework useful, not merely as seven points on which to concentrate during meditation, but as a map for observing some of the recurring themes through which we experience life.
When the Present Touches an Old Knot
There is another complication.
We do not process today's experience using only today's information.
The mind has an impressive archive - memories, old hurts, successes, failures, fears, expectations and ideas about ourselves.
So today's criticism may quietly bump into something much older.
Perhaps I have always felt that people underestimate me.
Perhaps recognition is especially important to me.
Perhaps failure frightens me.
Suddenly, I am not responding only to one sentence spoken this morning.
Several old files may have been opened.. sometimes without asking permission!
This is where the traditional idea of granthis becomes particularly interesting.
Granthi literally means a knot.
What a wonderfully human image.
We become attached to possessions, relationships, opinions, old hurts and identities.
Perhaps the comment has touched an old identity:
“I must be seen as capable.”
or
“People should appreciate what I do.”
Then the intensity of my reaction begins to make more sense.
The five-second comment has found a knot.
Fortunately, We Are Not Limited to Our First Reaction
Now imagine that somewhere in the middle of all this, I catch myself.
Wait a minute… why am I reacting so strongly?
The hurt may still be present. The body may still be tense. And the mind may still have several excellent arguments ready for immediate deployment.
But something has changed.
I am beginning to examine my reaction instead of simply being carried by it.
Perhaps I ask:
Is there some truth in what was said?
Am I reacting to the comment... or to my need to be appreciated?
Is an old experience getting mixed up with this one?
What response would actually help?
This is where Vijnanamaya Kosha becomes especially significant.
Perspective.
Understanding.
Discernment.
Choice.
The situation has not changed.
But my relationship with it has.
A little space has appeared between reaction and response.
But Now Something Curious Appears
Let us slow down here.
My body became tense.
I noticed it.
My energy shifted.
I noticed that too.
I felt hurt.
I knew I was hurt.
Thoughts started racing.
I could see those thoughts.
An old memory surfaced.
I knew I was remembering.
And now a rather interesting question arises:
How did I know all of this was happening?
Until now, everything we have explored has been part of the content of experience.
Body sensations are experienced.
Energy states are experienced.
Emotions are experienced.
Thoughts and memories are experienced.
Even the identity I am trying to defend can become something I observe.
So what is it that knows them?
Perhaps Awareness Isn't Another Box
It is tempting to extend the map we have been building.
We have spoken about the body, energy, mind and discernment as different dimensions of experience. So perhaps Awareness is simply one more dimension to be added to the picture.
But something doesn't quite fit.
Everything we have described so far is something we can experience or observe.
The body changes.
Energy changes.
Emotions and thoughts change.
Memories come and go.
Even our understanding of ourselves changes.
Yet somehow, all these changes are known.
This leads me to an interpretation I find increasingly meaningful:
Awareness may not be another component inside the architecture of human experience.
Perhaps it is that through which the entire architecture, and everything happening within it, is known.
This is the shift that Figure 5 tries to capture. Until now, our figures have explored what happens within experience. Here we step back and look at the whole architecture differently.
Figure 5: The Architecture within AwarenessA different way of seeing the whole picture
Not another part of the experience, but that through which the experience is known.
For me, this seemingly small shift changes the whole picture.
And Then Shiva and Shakti Appear…
At first, this may seem like an unexpected turn.
We usually encounter Shiva and Shakti as divine forms.. deities we worship, stories we have grown up with, images we see in temples and homes.
But what if, for a moment, we look at them not only as deities but also as symbols of something happening within us all the time?
Suddenly, the connection becomes fascinating.
Everything we have explored so far is in movement.
The body responds.
Prana moves.
Emotions rise and fall.
Thoughts appear and disappear.
Words are spoken.
Actions happen.
Life expresses itself.
This movement, energy and expression can be seen symbolically as Shakti.
And throughout all this movement, the movement is known.
That still, knowing presence can be seen symbolically as Shiva.
So perhaps Shiva and Shakti can also become a beautiful way of contemplating two inseparable dimensions of our experience:
Shakti — everything that moves, changes and expresses.
Shiva — the Awareness in which that movement is known.
Every thought is Shakti moving.
Every emotion is Shakti moving.
Every action is Shakti expressing.
And Awareness?
Perhaps that is where we begin to glimpse Shiva.
Not somewhere far away, but right here.. in the middle of an ordinary human experience that began with seven rather uncomfortable words:
“I thought you would have handled this better.”
Meditation Then Becomes a Laboratory
Seen this way, meditation need not simply be about stopping thoughts.
That is fortunate, because thoughts often appear not to have received that instruction.
Meditation can become a laboratory for exploring this invisible architecture.
I notice the body.
The breath.
Changes in energy.
Emotions.
Thoughts.
Memories.
Resistance.
Attachment.
And gradually the question may shift from:
“What am I experiencing?”
to:
“What is aware of this experience?”
That is a very different kind of exploration.
Ancient Maps and Modern Windows
There is a temptation here to make everything fit neatly together.
Prana must equal this.
A chakra must correspond exactly to that.
A kosha must be the ancient name for some modern physiological system.
I think we should be careful.
Modern science and the our contemplative traditions developed through different methods and often asked different kinds of questions.
Science investigates the brain, nervous system, hormones, breathing, cognition and behaviour.
Traditional contemplative systems gave us other maps.. shariras, koshas, prana, nadis, chakras and granthis.. largely emerging from introspection, contemplative practice and philosophical inquiry.
We don't have to force one vocabulary into the other.
Perhaps they are better seen as different windows looking at the extraordinary phenomenon of being human.
When Life Becomes the Practice
The next time somebody says something that gets under your skin.. and life is usually generous in providing such opportunities, try a small experiment.
Don't suppress the irritation.
Don't immediately try to become spiritual about it.
Just become curious.
What happened in my body?
Did my energy change?
What emotion appeared?
What story did my mind create?
Did this touch an older hurt, fear or expectation?
Can I see another perspective?
And then, perhaps after a little pause:
What is aware of all this happening?
You may not get an answer.
That is perfectly all right.
Perhaps this is one of those questions where finding a quick answer is less important than learning to stay with the question.
Because this invisible architecture isn't operating only when we meditate.
It is active while having breakfast.
While driving.
While reading a WhatsApp message.
While receiving praise.
While being ignored.
While arguing with someone we love.
Life keeps arriving.
Our inner architecture keeps responding.
Most of the time it happens so quickly that we simply call the result: “My experience.”
Perhaps there is value in occasionally slowing it down.
A situation.
The body responds.
Energy shifts.
The mind interprets.
The past sometimes joins in.
Discernment may appear.
A response emerges.
And somewhere along the way comes a rather remarkable discovery:
I am aware that all of this is happening.
Perhaps understanding the Invisible Architecture of Human Experience is ultimately not about creating a more complicated theory of ourselves.
Perhaps it is simply about understanding a little better how we experience life, creating a little more space between reaction and response, and becoming curious about that quiet presence through which the whole fascinating drama is known.




